Disagreeing Christianly

What separates divisiveness from “concerned” behavior?

We ministers can get too sensitive about people expressing alternative viewpoints. Perhaps with good reason. Those who do so are often the same who complain about everything…and often people don’t process their dissent well. They are overly harsh, or behave in a viral way, in an effort to infect others. A church’s ability to call out and correct this sort of behavior is going to be one of the primary factors in determining it’s future. All of this is true enough.

However, it seems to me that we must have some mechanism for people to voice legitimate concerns…and allow some room for people to continue to disagree without pitching a fit or being viewed with skepticism by all. How do we do this? How can we disagree Christianly in church? Obviously, Matthew 18 provides a guide for circumstances in which someone sins against someone. I also think it’s a good place to start for voicing criticism–though it’s not a blueprint for such a circumstance–a non-sin disagreement.

When someone comes to me with a sincere criticism, I try to take into account:

– The tone. Are the Fruit of the Spirit within 500 miles of this conversation? That goes for our tone as well.

– The frequency with which I hear from them. Is this just today’s special? If so, I need to avoid reinforcing their behavior by “hearing them out” unchallenged. A critical spirit dishonors God, and needs to be viewed and treated as sin. One way to unearth this is to ask, “Is there a track record of encouragement anywhere in this person’s “body of work?”

-Are they coming directly to me with this, or did I hear about it from somewhere else? If they come to me directly, that should be honored with an attentive listening. People deserve that any way…but especially in these cases.

-UNLESS, they are complaining to me about someone else. In that case, they need to be directed to that person first. Many Christians feel as though it’s their job to at least “listen” to whatever anyone ever says about others. The truth is that it reinforces that person’s immaturity and is unfair to those who aren’t present to defend themselves. One question to cut to the heart of this is to ask that person or think to yourself, “If so and so were here, what might they say you’re leaving out?” When I have asked that question, at least half the time the person revises their story–adding in crucial details that change the entire way a third party would view the story. At the very least, it makes them pause to consider the other person’s point of view.

I’d like to hear your thoughts on this. If you’re a minister, help us understand how you’d like to be approached with concerns. If not, help us understand how to handle concerns the best we can. Also, where is the line? When does it go from “concern” to divisive or damaging?

Dr. Tim Spivey is Lead Planter of New Vintage Church in San Diego, California. He is the author of numerous articles and one book, "Jesus: The Powerful Servant." A sought after speaker for events, Tim also serves as Adjunct Professor of Religion at Pepperdine University. Tim serves as a church consultant, and his writings are featured on ChurchLeaders.com, Church Executive magazine, Faith Village, Sermon Central, and Giving Rocket.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.

Share Your Thoughts

3 thoughts on “Disagreeing Christianly

  1. Matthew 18 – the clearest teaching of Jesus that is almost never applied. The most troubling lack of application is from church leaders that believe the way to get true “intel” from the church is to allow critics to remain anonymous.

  2. As a minister if someone disagree’s with me I would hope they would come to me in a spirit of love. I have no problems with people disagreeing with me, in fact I believe this is a great way to learn.
    As a younger minister I make time to meet with and listen to older members of the Church. For the most part the way I do ministry and my views differ from them.
    I have found this to be helpful. We all have the same goal just a different avenue to get there.
    Thank you for your post and God bless.

  3. This conversation also impacts the way Christians use the internet/email when disagreeing. I told someone a while back “would you speak in person to someone the way you come across in your emails with writing in caps, bold font, and some speech that seems slanderous?” When we talk face to face, it ought to remind us that we are talking to an actual person…brother/sister in Christ. That ought to change how we voice our disagreements, criticisms, etc…
    Grace and peace,
    Rex